643 Dayton Street
The Rentschler House
The Rentschler House is not only significant for its architecture and historical context, but it also represents the success story of an immigrant who became an integral part of the Hamilton community. George Adam Rentschler's contribution to the city's growth and development is undeniable, and his legacy lives on through his family's continued involvement in manufacturing. Rentschler was a partner in the cast iron manufacturing firm of Sohn and Rentschler. The house that bears his name is a testament to his achievements and his lasting impact on the community. The Rentschler House's unique design and architectural features make it a standout among the historic homes in Hamilton.
644 Dayton Street
This Victorian home was built in the 1870 as the residence of Postmaster John McKee and his wife Sarah (Beckett) McKee. It is the second residential home ever built on Dayton Street and the oldest surviving home.
1003 Dayton Street
This Colonial Revival residence was built sometime between 1897 and 1900. It features many Queen Anne details such as the arched stained-glass windows & the wrap-around porch. Local historic directories show a widow, E.C. Falconer, lived here in 1900.
25,27, & 29 North Ninth Street
This former commercial building first appeared in the tax records as the Miami Valley Hosiery Mill. In 1892, owner Charles Zwick added extensive brick and frame additions and converted the building into three row-house style residences.
937 Dayton Street
This large Queen Anne home was built by Charles & Susan Fitton in 1894. Charles owned a carriage company, but interestingly the original deed listed Susan as the owner of the home.
712 Dayton Street
This Prairie style home with Italian Renaissance details was built in 1910 by William Shuler of Shuler & Benninghofen. The 8200 sq ft interior features a Rookwood Fireplace, quartered oak molding, leaded windows, a solid mahogany beamed ceiling. There are 22 rooms including 6 bathrooms. Be sure to note the flood high water marker on the porch. It is currently the single- family home.
610 Dayton Street
The house & carriage house are two of the finest examples of half-timbered Queen Anne architecture in the city. The McKinney House was built circa 1883 by Robert McKinney, secretary & treasurer of the Niles Tool Works.
807 Dayton Street
This home was built in the 1890s for Christian Benninghofen, a prominent industrialist.